Why I break the law

Monday, July 26th, 2010 01:57 pm
15 - minutes by which I missed the start of Sherlock broadcast on BBC1
45 - minutes spent attempting (without success) to install iPlayer desktop
04 - minutes watching via iPlayer online before the browser hung
00 - number of repeats of this episode on non-HD BBC this week, at least according to BBC site
14 - minutes to download ev0l illegal torrent (seeded by over 10,000 users)

ethics and law

Friday, April 9th, 2010 04:31 pm
Via BoingBoing, an illegal download is not necessarily unethical.

Which is the distinction I was probably trying to make in last year's post re PirateBay.

Lately:
- I've purchased ebooks that I already own in dead-tree versions, and didn't that turn out well;
- I've downloaded an illegal copy of a CD I own that won't play any more;
- I've even *gasp* done it the other way round, and bought a legal copy of a movie after watching a downloaded version.

There are some shades of grey here, and some ethical issues, that could do with test cases. (Do not get me started on the Digital Economy Bill. Though presumably they cannot prosecute* if you are using illegal-content websites but downloading / sharing files that are not illegal, e.g. out-of-copyright musical performances and public-domain text.)

*but will have a bloody good go, or rather will not give a damn what you are downloading

PirateBay Verdict

Friday, April 17th, 2009 01:50 pm
There is one question very conspicuously missing from the BBC's online coverage so far:

So, is everything on PirateBay an illegal download?

That'd be a big fat NO, then.

My last three PirateBay downloads, all of which seem to me no more illegal than taping off the radio*:
- Primeval S03E03 (UK television, first broadcast Saturday: ITV, if that makes a difference)
- SF Library's Tepper section (attempting to grab e-text of a book I own 2 copies of -- one was on loan, one's in storage)
- Haydn - Nelson Mass (I have a CD somewhere but could not locate it)

edit to add
I was not intending the above as a list of legal downloads -- hence the phrase 'no more illegal than taping off the radio', which, yes, is illegal -- but as grey areas. Here are some less-grey areas:
- Lawrence Lessig's Free Culture (PDF)
- complete works of Shakespeare as text files
- Rachmaninoff playing his own Piano Concerto #2 (1931)



There's definitely a great deal of pirated material available online, and there are many grey areas: I think it's disingenuous to report the matter as though everything downloaded is pirated content, robbing artistes of their rightful reward.

*for my younger readers: 'radio' is what we had before streaming music on the interweb; 'taping' is a means by which sound could be recorded onto magnetic tape. Kind of like ripping an MP3 but slower and less robust. Retro chic!

Torchwoodgate

Monday, September 8th, 2008 03:49 pm
Further to this morning's post about whether it is Right / Ethical / Legal for an author of a published, dead-tree book to quote extensively (up to 400 words at a time) from LJ posts, attributing them to the authors but not contacting said authors ...

- Selected extracts from author's response to complaints. Includes the priceless comment "I read out [author's] reply at work. The sound you hear if you listen carefully is a room full of high priced lawyers dissolving into hysterics."

- Daily Mail paid a blogger for using his material under similar circumstances -- but only after he invoiced them. Some interesting legal points there.

January 2026

S M T W T F S
     1 2 3
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags